The September 5, 2025, episode of WWE SmackDown from the Allstate Arena in Chicago delivered a loaded card full of memorable moments, shocking returns, and intense in-ring action. Headlined by John Cena’s emotional farewell to Chicago, an explosive United States Championship open challenge featuring Sami Zayn, and a historic return of AJ Lee, the show ignited fan excitement while stirring mixed reactions.

Here’s a comprehensive look at the three things we loved and three things we hated from WWE SmackDown 9/5/25, drawing from reports by WWE.com, Fightful, Wrestling Inc., and independent sources.

3 Things We Loved About WWE SmackDown 9/5/2025

1. AJ Lee’s Long-Awaited Return Stuns WWE Universe

One of the biggest surprises came when AJ Lee returned to WWE SmackDown after a lengthy absence, marking a seismic moment on the show. Her arrival injected fresh energy into the women’s division and sparked immediate speculation about new storylines and possible title pursuits. Sources close to WWE insiders revealed her comeback had been kept tightly under wraps to maximize impact[5].

AJ’s presence was a delightful nostalgic moment for fans and a clear sign WWE is serious about shaking up the current landscape. Her charisma and connection with the audience added a spark missing from recent women’s programming[5].

2. John Cena’s Final Chicago Appearance Brings the Crowd to Their Feet

John Cena delivered a heartfelt promo reflecting on his career and journey in front of the passionate Chicago crowd, making it clear this appearance was special. Cena thanked fans for their unwavering support throughout his many years with WWE on SmackDown. As Wrestling Inc. and Wrestleview noted, the emotion in the arena was palpable and underscored Cena’s legendary status[1][3].

While his scheduled US Title match against Sami Zayn ended in a No Contest, Cena’s display of respect and fight validated his legacy in the city and on WWE television[2][4].

3. Aleister Black vs. Damian Priest Delivers a Hard-Hitting Showcase

The clash between Aleister Black and Damian Priest was a highlight in terms of in-ring storytelling and intensity. Reported by multiple sources including Wrestling Inc. and Wrestleview, the match saw both competitors pushing their limits with technical strikes, submission maneuvers, and high-impact sequences.

Black ultimately picked up the victory with his signature Black Mass finisher, solidifying his momentum on SmackDown. The chemistry between the two added a compelling dynamic to the roster’s midcard[1][3].

3 Things We Hated About WWE SmackDown 9/5/2025

1. US Championship Match Ends in No Contest After Brock Lesnar’s Brutal Interference

The much-anticipated US Title match between Sami Zayn and John Cena concluded abruptly and controversially when Brock Lesnar stormed the ring, attacking both men with a double F5 finisher. Although this guaranteed an intense future showdown at Wrestlepalooza, fans expecting a clean finish were left frustrated.

As detailed by Barnett’s live review and Fightful, the interference overshadowed the match’s promising build-up and left the crowd divided. The booking decision drew criticism for stalling the title scene, despite the excitement Lesnar’s return added[2][4].

2. Becky Lynch’s Ambiguous Role in the Backstage Storyline

While Becky Lynch’s arrival in the building was a notable moment, her backstage segment with Nick Aldis was criticized for lacking clarity and meaningful advancement. Wrestling Inc. pointed out that Lynch’s presence seemed forced and failed to capitalize fully on the momentum built by her recent character work or any connection with CM Punk in attendance[3].

Some fans lamented missed opportunities, feeling the storyline progression should have been more defined or impactful given the star power involved.

3. Overbooking and Frequent Interruptions Hindered Match Flow

Several matches throughout the night, including the main events, suffered from excessive interference, run-ins, or abrupt stoppages that fractured the pacing. Reports from Wrestleview and Sports Illustrated noted that while the action was intense, constant disruptions made it difficult for fans to stay fully engaged.

This pattern is a growing criticism of WWE’s booking style, where live momentum often gives way to setting up future angles at the expense of satisfying conclusions on the night[1][5].

Additional Highlights and Backstage Notes

• CM Punk’s Mystery Appearance: Although initially pulled from the lineup, CM Punk did make an appearance, which caught fans off guard and hinted at new feuds or alliances per Fightful coverage[2].

• Giulia vs. Michin Women’s US Title Match: Giulia successfully defended her newly introduced Women’s United States Championship against challenger Michin, adding prestige to the newly established title on SmackDown[2].

• Behind the Scenes: According to a WWE insider, the decision to bring back AJ Lee was strategic, aimed at revitalizing SmackDown’s women’s division and increasing viewer ratings in the crucial fall quarter.

• Future Directions: The lesion of Lesnar’s attacks clearly set the stage for a high-stakes Wrestlepalooza main event against John Cena, a blockbuster match that WWE expects to headline their biggest show of the year[1][4].

SEO Keywords:

WWE SmackDown 9/5/2025, AJ Lee return WWE, John Cena final Chicago, Sami Zayn vs John Cena US Title, Brock Lesnar WWE interference, Aleister Black Damian Priest match, WWE SmackDown results, WWE Wrestlepalooza 2025, Becky Lynch WWE storyline

The September 5 episode of WWE SmackDown ultimately combined electrifying returns, heartfelt tribute moments, and hard-fought battles—while struggling with booking choices that left some fans craving cleaner finishes. With Wrestlepalooza looming and major stars converging, the coming weeks promise epic storytelling and unforgettable matches highlighted by AJ Lee’s return and John Cena’s farewell tour milestones. Sources from Fightful, Wrestling Inc., and Wrestleview closely track the evolving narrative arcs on SmackDown as WWE builds towards its autumn peak.