Matt Riddle, the former WWE Superstar known as “The Original Bro,” has recently found himself embroiled in multiple controversies, prompting sharp criticism from notable figures in wrestling media and peers alike. On the latest episode of the Cheap Heat podcast, host Peter Rosenberg delivered a blunt critique of Riddle’s conduct during his WWE tenure as well as his recent inflammatory comments, highlighting a growing unease in the wrestling community over Riddle’s actions and statements[Reference].

Rosenberg’s comments come amid a storm of public disputes involving Riddle, who has faced backlash following his no-show at a charity wrestling event in the UK and subsequent controversial remarks regarding sexual assault allegations. These incidents have fueled debate over his professionalism and public conduct since parting ways with WWE.

Peter Rosenberg Calls Out Matt Riddle’s Behavior and Opportunities

As one of professional wrestling’s prominent commentators, Peter Rosenberg did not hold back on his assessment of Matt Riddle during the Cheap Heat podcast. Rosenberg described Riddle as a prime example of talent who was given significant opportunities by WWE but failed to maintain a responsible or respectful attitude. Rosenberg criticized Riddle for what he characterized as unprofessional behavior, implying that Riddle’s actions and recent remarks reflect poorly on him and the broader wrestling industry.

This critique echoes concerns fans and insiders have voiced since Riddle’s release from WWE, where he was once a United States Champion and a popular figure. Sources from WWE.com and Fightful have noted that Riddle’s in-ring talent was never in question, but his off-screen conduct has increasingly overshadowed his career achievements in recent years.

No-Show Controversy at Global Wrestling Kingdom Event

Reports emerged in late August 2025 that Matt Riddle had no-showed Global Wrestling Kingdom’s debut event in Barnsley, England—a show purportedly raising money for charities supporting survivors of domestic abuse and homeless veterans[1][3]. Multiple wrestling news outlets like Cultaholic.com and PWInsider covered the story extensively, adding fuel to the fire.

Riddle responded publicly via Twitter/X, disputing several claims. He explained that the travel arrangements booked for him were problematic—a flight booked far in advance with no meet-and-greet or additional appearances scheduled—rendering it impractical for him to commit. Riddle also stated the event’s charity status was a last-minute change and denied refusing to repay deposits, calling the accusations “lies.” However, his response was delivered with frustration and profanity, which did little to quell critics[1].

Fallout from Controversial Sexual Assault Comments

Riddle’s troubles escalated when he made dismissive and inflammatory remarks about sexual assault and domestic violence (SA and DV), referencing the 2020 #SpeakingOut movement allegations against him. During an online appearance, Riddle derisively referred to the “MeToo bullsh*t,” drawing ire from both fans and promoters[2].

The immediate consequence was his removal from SiouxperCon, a South Dakota comic convention scheduled for October 2025. Organizers issued an official statement condemning his comments as misaligned with the event’s mission and values. They promised refunds for fans who purchased photo ops and pledged to donate a portion of ticket proceeds to The Compass Center, a support organization for SA and DV survivors[2][3].

Support From Former WWE Superstar Paul London

Despite the controversy, not all voices have turned against Riddle. Former WWE star Paul London recently defended Riddle on the Masters of Wrestling podcast, emphasizing Riddle’s genuine nature and charitable character[4]. London expressed disbelief that Riddle would intentionally disrespect fans or charitable causes, praising his sincerity and straightforward demeanor both in and out of the ring.

This endorsement sheds light on the complexity surrounding Riddle’s public image: while some insiders highlight professional lapses and problematic remarks, others maintain that Riddle is misunderstood and essentially a good person who made regrettable mistakes.

Wrestling Industry Reflection and Accountability

The wrestling industry continues grappling with how to handle allegations of misconduct and the accountability of performers beyond the ring. Riddle’s ongoing controversies underscore the tension between talent marketplace behavior and social responsibility.

Sources close to WWE have indicated that while creative and management had growing concerns about Riddle’s attitude and reliability, his work ethic in the ring was never disputed. Nonetheless, public relations challenges arising from off-screen controversies weighed heavily on the company’s decision to part ways with him.

The attitude expressed by Peter Rosenberg and the swift reactions from promoters and conventions highlight a broader cultural shift in professional wrestling, wherein performers are increasingly held to higher standards of conduct—with consequences for failing to meet them.

What’s Next for Matt Riddle?

As of September 2025, Matt Riddle remains a polarizing figure in pro wrestling. While he has denied some accusations and maintained readiness to clear misunderstandings, his repeated involvement in public disputes has damaged his reputation. His booking cancellations and removal from fan events serve as a tangible impact.

According to a WWE insider, Riddle has expressed frustration with the narrative but is reportedly consulting with his management about his professional path forward. Whether he can rehabilitate his image or continue to secure prominent bookings remains uncertain.

Fans and industry observers will be watching closely to see if Riddle can move past these controversies or if they will continue to cast a shadow over a career that once seemed destined for the top.

Sources: Cheap Heat podcast, WWE.com, Fightful, PWInsider, Cultaholic.com, SiouxperCon official statements, WrestlingInc, Sportskeeda, Ringside News